To acquire wisdom, one must observe

Short Story: A Minor Indiscretion

Out the floor-to-ceiling-window next to our booth at Prime Catch, the sun shimmers off Boston Harbor. Damn, the UV must be close to 10. Too bad I’m stuck in here with this asshole instead of out tanning on my pink and green striped picnic blanket on the grass in the Public Gardens. Greg chose this place because when I was 10, lobster was my favorite food, so according to his hockey puck of a brain, it obviously still must be. I don’t even eat shellfish anymore, not that he would know that. Plus, this place reeks like the New England Aquarium and the patrons here all look like they predate the invention of color TV. I’m pretty sure across the room from us, I just heard a woman, with a face that screams “Grandma in an LL Bean catalogue,” ask her lunch date (dinner? who knows, maybe 3:30 is dinner time for these social security recipients) if “that handsome young fella Paul Newman is still alive.” 

God, was there a jailbreak at the Back Bay Center for Senior Living or something? Just then, a stocky waiter in a crisp white button-down and perfectly pressed black slacks appeared at our table with our entree: Massachusetts’ finest grilled lobster with a tangy lemon butter dipping sauce. 

You know what, at least Greg is trying, and he is my father (I took a paternity test when I was 19 just to make sure), whether I like him or not (and trust me, it’s not). Maybe I should indulge his haggard attempts at reconnecting. And dammit does that beautiful scarlet lobster claw look good. The smell of butter invades my nostrils like teenage girls storming a Brandy Mellville. Fine. I relent and take a bite, just to placate my father, of course. There are vegetarians who go years without meat, and then when they have a bite of wagyu steak, they nod and say “not bad, but I really didn’t miss it.” Let me tell you about those people. They are either lying, stupid, or so simpleminded that they could successfully brainwash themselves into believing this nonsense they are spouting.

No, when I take my first bite of lobster in six years, I am suddenly that 10-year-old girl in my Cinderella shirt and sparkly headband that just wanted my dad to give me another push on the tire swing after chowing down on lobster rolls in the backyard of Grandpa’s house on the Cape. The little girl in a Big Papi jersey two sizes too big learning how to swing a bat from her smiling dad. The toddler sitting next to her father at her first hockey game, screaming so loud in jubilation that by the end of the night, her voice was a mere whisper.

Screw it, let’s pretend like we have a normal father-daughter relationship (whatever the hell that means) and let me tell him what is going on in my life. So I blab about my friend group. Cassie is going to grad school at Penn. Syd started at a tech startup in New York a few weeks ago. Charlie is joining the marines. And the list goes on. He stops after each one, offering a remark or two that sort of makes him sound like a man who is close with his daughter. And that doesn’t betray the fact that before this conversation, he more likely would be able to successfully name the Sox’s entire bullpen before he could name a single one of my friends. He asks if I have any idea about what I want to do with my Art History degree. I give him a whole spiel about that that basically amounts to “I got no fucking clue.” But I can’t tell him that. And he doesn’t wanna push me so he nods and says, “interesting,” doing his best to hold back the ‘I told you so’ in his voice. 

Then he goes to a place that I think both of us didn’t want to wind up. But yet here we are. “So, um, any guys in your life,” he inquires. What the hell, in for a haircut, in for a blowout, “yeah, actually. I was seeing this one guy Eric for a while and that was going well. At least until two weeks ago.” 

My dad looks perplexed, his eyebrow raised and his mouth slightly agape. “What happened two weeks ago?” he asks. 

“Well,” I pause, “He and his friend, knowing that I rarely lock the door to my apartment, came in one day and dumped glitter everywhere. In my shoes, on the bed, on the living room carpet. It was a mess. And now everytime I put on a pair of shoes or open a cabinet I see shimmering red and blue sparkles.”

“Why in God’s name would he do that?” asks my dad. 

“Let’s just say that he caught me doing something that I shouldn’t have with a friend of his,” I answer sheepishly. 

“What did you do?” my father said, raising his voice enough that even LL Bean Grannie turned and glanced to look at our corner booth.   

“It’s not that bad,” I said to my father, in a voice 30 decibels lower than the booming one he just employed. But I can see the rage building up inside him like the pop from a catcher’s mitt getting louder and louder as the pitcher gets warmed up, his fastball velocity climbing on the radar gun. My dad all of a sudden looked as though he was about to pretend that the past nine years hadn’t happened and he was just the perfect model of the ideal modern father about to teach his little girl an important lesson about respecting guys. I put my hand up before he could say a word, “Don’t worry, Dad. It was just a minor indiscretion.” 

+ posts
Full Name
First Name
Last Name
School Year(s) On Staff
Skip to content