To acquire wisdom, one must observe

Bring back physical video game discs

On Thursday, Nov. 19, millions of people purchased Rockstar’s next big game, ‘Grand Theft Auto (GTA) VI’, which was finally released after a 13-year wait. With more than $1.5 billion in presales and forecasts of up to $5 billion in first-week sales, the continuation of the popular franchise is projected to be the biggest video game launch in history. For GTA fans, this marks an exciting opportunity to enjoy the next chapter of the beloved franchise.

It also marks the end of an era. GTA VI is only available to download; it does not come on a physical disc. Even purchasing a copy in-store will just give you a download code to redeem yourself. The next generation of gamers will never get to experience the excitement of unwrapping a birthday present to see the most recent hit game or cult classic. Entering a download code simply doesn’t provide the same holiday magic as putting in a disc for the first time.

Perhaps it is unsurprising that physical discs for video games are a dying breed. After all, physical discs for other types of content have long since gone extinct. Streaming services overtook DVDs as the most common way to watch an old movie in 2015, and Best Buy and Target both stopped selling them in 2023. CDs suffered an even earlier death, with sales peaking in 2000 before MP3 players and streaming services eroded their market share. Physical video games managed to survive into the digital age for far longer than most other media. 

Perhaps it was inevitable that video game companies would eventually try to enter the modern world. Physical discs can be damaged; digital downloads cannot. Physical copies of games can be stolen; digital copies, theoretically, cannot. Some consoles use discs and some use cartridges, often abandoning older games to an ever-shrinking number of players who own old consoles. Offering old games as a download solves this problem, ensuring that games don’t get lost as console technology progresses. Given these benefits, it comes as no surprise that game companies are choosing to go digital. 

But as consumers, we should not so readily accept this transition. Nostalgia is not the only reason to keep producing games on discs. Physical discs provide actual ownership of a game, playable on any device rather than just one console. At one point during our childhood, we’ve all taken our brand new game to our friend’s house, sharing the experience of trying out a game together. This was good for the companies, too. If our friend liked the game, they might have even bought it themselves. 

Owning physical discs of games ensures that you keep control of your games if your console breaks. A physical disc of a PlayStation (PS) 5 game can be put into any PS5. A downloaded game is limited to just the device it was downloaded on. If that device breaks, it’s possible that all of your downloaded games will be gone. In the past, it was common for free games to be downloadable, while games that cost money were available only in-stores. This meant that when your console broke, you could replace your games for no additional cost; you already owned hard copies of all the ones that cost anything. When games like GTA VI that are download-only cost $80, it forces players to choose between spending even more money or losing their favorite games. Consoles are already expensive enough; when one breaks, it shouldn’t cost more just to keep your games. 

Physical discs also protect gaming against enshittification. Enshittification is the process where a product starts off great for consumers until a large customer base is built up, then the experience is gradually made worse once customers are locked in. Take streaming services as an example. Streaming services lured customers away from cable and DVDs by offering them cheap access to unlimited movies and TV shows for a very low price, all with no ads. As more users started to join streaming services, they gradually raised their prices while offering an ever-shrinking catalogue of available content and showing ads. Now customers pay more than ever for streaming services whose combined offerings include less than half of all movies. 

Without physical discs to keep control in the hands of players, gaming faces this same bleak future. In April, Sony updated the PlayStation’s terms of service to state that players do not own the games that they download; purchasing a game simply gives a player a non-transferable license to play the game. If Sony closes someone’s account, they lose access to all of their games, and all of the money they spent buying them. Physical discs provide a bulwark against the shift into the world of subscription-based models, where consumers own nothing and mega-corporations control everything. We should not abandon them so quickly.

+ posts
Full Name
First Name
Last Name
School Year(s) On Staff
Skip to content